Athletes who achieve a 3.2 or better GPA on a 4.0 scale are recognized as National Wrestling Coaching Organization Scholar All-Americans. The NWCA also recognizes the top 30 academic teams (by overall GPA) each year.

NWCA Division III Academic Top 25
12th in 1999 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.018
6th in 2000 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.238
10th in 2001 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.147
18th in 2002 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.138
20th in 2005 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.132
17th in 2006 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.195
9th in 2007 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.284
17th in 2008 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.280
19th in 2009 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.229
25th in 2015 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.333
29th in 2016 with a cumulative team GPA of 3.130

NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans
Michael Bikulcius (2018)
Joby Bodi (2012)
Josh Bouie (2016, 2018)
Cowan Brown (2009, 2010)
Joel Curry (2000)
Dustin Docter (2006)
Jason Fitzenreider (2009)
Nathan Fitzenreider (2010, 2012)
Noah Fitzenreider (2005)
Ricky Flores (2001, 2002)
Dan Franch (1987, 1988)
James Ford (2019)
Cam Hayes (2019)
Matt Janosek (2000, 2001)
Adam Johnson (2006, 2007, 2008)
Jeff Jones (2002)
Eric Kirkmam (2016)
Emonte Logan (2018)
Marcello Macellaio (2019)
Dylan Mahler (2014, 2015)
Derrick Martin (1993, 1994, 1995)
Moe Mitchell (2018)
Don Mueller (1994, 1995)
Jason Nako (2019, 2022)
Blake Olson (2015)
Brad Pearson (2002)
Anthony Rink (2017, 2019)
Nick Santos (2013, 2014)
David Schultz (2005)
Greg Schroeder (2008)
Miguel Silva (2000)
Jason Smith (1995)
Darrick Snyder (1998, 1999, 2000)
Chris Talmadge (1997)
Tyler Vittal (2016, 2017, 2018, 2019)
Ben Williamson (2019)
Ben Youel (2006, 2007, 2008, 2009)