Bill Shatzer NAIA Little All-American 1941	Tom Dean NAIA Little All-American Honorable Mention - 1958	Jack Nothacker NAIA Little All-American 1959	John Turpin NAIA Little All-American 1960
Luther Selbo NAIA Little All-American Honorable Mention - 1967	Bill Shupryt Associated Press Little All-American 1976	Bernard Verner Associated Press Little All-American 1978	Mike Wozniak CoSIDA All-American Third Team - 1980
Tom Murray All-American 1983	Jim Witte AFCA All-American 1997	Ben Hare Football Gazette All-American Third Team - 2004	Lenny Radtke Football Gazette All-American First Team - 2004, 2005 D3football.com All-American Second Team - 2004, 2005 AFCA All-American - 2005 Associated Press Little All-American - 2005
Tyke Spencer Football Gazette All-American First Team - 2004 Second Team - 2005 D3football.com All-American Third Team - 2005	Tim Bellazzini Football Gazette All-American Third Team - 2005 Second Team - 2006 Honorable Mention D3football.com All-American 2006	Don Kasper Football Gazette All-America Third Team - 2006 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2007	Matt Wenger Associated Press Little All-American 2010 AFCA All-American 2008, 2010 D3football.com All-American Second Team - 2008 First Team - 2010 D3football.com Defensive Player of the Year - 2010
Josh Delancy AFCA All-American - 2009 D3football.com All-American Third Team - 2009	Kyle Antos D3football.com All-American First Team - 2010	Valente Garza D3football.com All-American Third Team - 2010	Kyle Fiedorowicz AFCA All-American - 2011 D3football.com All-American First Team - 2011
Peter Bulandr D3football.com All-American First Team - 2011	Josh Mitchell D3football.com All-American Honorable Mention - 2011	Spencer Stanek AFCA All-American - 2013 D3football.com All-American Second Team - 2013	Shane Dierking D3football.com All-American First Team - 2013
Alex Tripp D3football.com All-American Second Team - 2013	Nick Slezak D3football.com All-American Third Team - 2013	Jace Werkheiser D3football.com All-American Honorable Mention - 2013	Eric Knaperek AFCA All-American - 2015 Associated Press Little All-America Second Team - 2015 xxx
Joe Fehrle D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention - 2016 Second Team - 2017 AFCA All-America First Team - 2017 Associated Press Little All-America Second Team - 2017	Austin Breunig Associated Press Little All-America First Team - 2017 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2017	Sharmore Clarke Associated Press All-America First Team - 2018, 2019, 2021 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2018 First Team - 2019, 2021 AFCA All-America Second Team - 2019, 2021	Derik Judka Associated Press Little All-America First Team - 2018 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2018
Broc Rutter Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2018 First Team - 2019 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2018 First Team - 2019 AFCA All-America Second Team - 2019	Andrew Kamienski AFCA All-America First Team - 2019, 2021 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2019, 2021 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2019, 2021	Jake Beesley Associated Press All-America First Team - 2019, 2021 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2019 First Team - 2021	Ethan Greenfield Associated Press All-America First Team - 2019, 2021, 2022 D3football.com All-America Second Team - 2019 First Team - 2021, 2022 AFCA All-America First Team - 2022
Dan Gilroy Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2021 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2021	Jeske Maples Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2021, 2024 First Team - 2022, 2023 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2022, 2023, 2024 AFCA All-America Second Team - 2023	Ben Wong D3football.com All-America Fourth Team - 2021	DeAngelo Hardy Associated Press All-America First Team - 2022, 2023 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2022, 2023 AFCA All-America Second Team - 2023
Dan Lester AFCA All-America Second Team - 2022 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2022 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2022	Antwain Walker Associated Press All-America First Team - 2022 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2022 Second Team - 2023	Martin Egbo AFCA All-America Second Team - 2023 D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2023 Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2023	Luke Lehnen AFCA All-America First Team - 2023 D3football.com All-America First Team - 2023, 2024 D3football.com National Offensive Player of the Year - 2023 Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2023 First Team - 2024 Associated Press National Offensive Player of the Year - 2024
BJ Adamchik D3football.com All-America Third Team - 2023 Second Team - 2024	Julian Bell D3football.com All-America Second Team - 2023 Associated Press All-America Second Team - 2023	Joey Lombardi D3football.com All-America Fourth Team - 2023 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2023	Sam Pryor D3football.com All-America Second Team - 2023 First Team - 2024 AFCA Coaches' All-America First Team - 2024 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2024 Walter Camp Foundation All-America First Team - 2024
Joe Sacco D3football.com All-America Second Team - 2023 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2023	Jarod Thornton D3football.com All-America First Team - 2023 Associated Press All-America First Team - 2023	John Sullivan D3football.com All-America Second Team - 2024	Zack Orr D3football.com All-America Fourth Team - 2024