2010 (12-1)
North Central 41, Cornell 7
North Central 52, Olivet 9
North Central 20, Wis.-Eau Claire 6
North Central 43, Carthage 8
North Central 34, Augustana 14
North Central 38, Millikin 7
North Central 30, Illinois Wesleyan 7
North Central 47, Elmhurst 13
North Central 28, Wheaton 6
North Central 61, North Park 7
North Central 57, St. Norbert 7
North Central 28, Ohio Northern 9
Wis.-Whitewater 20, North Central 10

2011 (10-2)
Redlands 35, North Central 29
North Central 70, Bethel (Tenn.) 26
North Central 86, Olivet 14
North Central 24, Carthage 0
North Central 24, Augustana 3
North Central 61, Millikin 14
North Central 24, Illinois Wesleyan 0
North Central 51, Elmhurst 10
North Central 33, Wheaton 7
North Central 35, North Park 0
North Central 59, Dubuque 13
Wabash 29, North Central 28

2012 (9-3)
Wis.-La Crosse 21, North Central 17
North Central 42, Redlands 16
North Central 37, Wis.-Stout 10
North Central 44, Elmhurst 10
North Central 42, Millikin 22
North Central 58, North Park 17
North Central 42, Carthage 10
North Central 52, Illinois Wesleyan 0
Wheaton 35, North Central 21
North Central 37, Augustana 6
North Central 41, Cal Lutheran 21
Linfield 30, North Central 14

2013 (13-1)
North Central 41, Wis.-La Crosse 24
North Central 41, Wis.-Stout 14
North Central 27, Wis.-Stevens Point 7
North Central 31, Elmhurst 14
North Central 55, Millikin 7
North Central 42, North Park 0
North Central 72, Carthage 20
North Central 46, Illinois Wesleyan 17
North Central 35, Wheaton 16
North Central 53, Augustana 14
North Central 63, Albion 7
North Central 52, Wis.-Platteville 24
North Central 41, Bethel (Minn.) 17
Mount Union 41, North Central 40

2014 (8-2)
North Central 51, St. Norbert 17
North Central 28, Wis.-Platteville 7
Wis.-Stevens Point 34, North Central 27
North Central 47, Millikin 13
North Central 58, North Park 26
North Central 53, Carthage 23
Wheaton 34, North Central 31
North Central 45, Illinois Wesleyan 24
North Central 43, Augustana 14
North Central 38, Elmhurst 31

2015 (7-3)
North Central 41, Trine 7
Wis.-Platteville 35, North Central 28, OT
Wesley 50, North Central 49
North Central 49, Millikin 21
North Central 47, North Park 20
North Central 41, Carthage 17
Wheaton 17, North Central 9
North Central 33, Illinois Wesleyan 15
North Central 27, Augustana 10
North Central 56, Elmhurst 21

2016 (11-1)
North Central 35, Robert Morris-Chicago 21
North Central 38, Webber International 21
North Central 34, Illinois Wesleyan 7
North Central 42, Millikin 7
North Central 35, North Park 14
North Central 35, Wheaton 25
North Central 42, Augustana 21
North Central 62, Carroll 7
North Central 34, Carthage 21
North Central 59, Elmhurst 17
North Central 41, Rose-Hulman 7
Wheaton 31, North Central 14

2017 (10-2)
North Central 33, Robert Morris-Chicago 31
North Central 26, Illinois Wesleyan 13
North Central 51, Millikin 21
North Central 43, Washington (Mo.) 24
North Central 33, North Park 0
Wheaton 42, North Central 20
North Central 54, Augustana 2
North Central 60, Carroll 21
North Central 43, Carthage 20
North Central 49, Elmhurst 7
North Central 17, Saint John's (Minn.) 7
Wisconsin-Oshkosh 42, North Central 21

2018 (10-2)
North Central 70, Lake Forest 14
North Central 32, Washington-St. Louis 19
North Central 35, North Park 0
Wheaton 52, North Central 30
North Central 48, Augustana 10
North Central 59, Carroll 0
North Central 26, Carthage 14
North Central 55, Elmhurst 0
North Central 38, Illinois Wesleyan 20
North Central 55, Millikin 12
North Central 52, Hanover 0
Bethel (Minn.) 27, North Central 24

2019 (14-1)
North Central 43, Christopher Newport (Virginia) 13
North Central 46, Washington-St. Louis 13
North Central 77, North Park 0
Wheaton 35, North Central 21
North Central 42, Augustana 14
North Central 62, Carroll 3
North Central 49, Carthage 6
North Central 82, Elmhurst 7
North Central 69, Illinois Wesleyan 14
North Central 59, Millikin 32
North Central 51, Wabash 15
North Central 59, Mount Uniont 52
North Central 31, Delaware Valley (Pennsylvania) 14
North Central 45, Muhlenberg (Pennsylvania) 14
North Central 41, Wisconsin-Whitewater 14 (national championship)