Wheaton College 21, North Central College 20
 
125 - Jeff Cook (NCC) won by forfeit
133 - Brandon Malone (NCC) won by forfeit
141 - Layten Binion (NCC) def. Eric Wales (Wheaton), 11-3 major decision
149 - Ben Williamson (NCC) def. Zachary Harrell (Wheaton), 8-0 major decision
157 - Jared Fekete (Wheaton) def. Josh Tardy (NCC), 4-1 decision
165 - Frank Aiello (Wheaton) def. Matt Marcotte (NCC), 15-9 decision
174 - Stephen Aiello (Wheaton) def. Eric Kirkman (NCC), 8-6 decision (OT)
184 - Logan Walkup (Wheaton) def. Vince Pizzo (NCC), 3-1 decision (OT)
197 - Mikey Swider (Wheaton) def. Tyler Vittal (NCC), 4-0 decision
285 - Max Gierke (Wheaton) def. Emonte Logan (NCC), by fall (1:25)