Tom Dean NAIA All-District 1958, 1959, 1960	John Turpin NAIA All-District 1959	Dan Van Mill NAIA All-District 1960	Luther Selbo NAIA All-District 1967
Jim Witte Football Gazette All-North Region Third Team - 1996	Ben Hare Football Gazette All-North Region Second Team - 2004 Third Team - 2005	Kam Kniss Football Gazette All-North Region Third Team - 2004, 2006 Second Team - 2005 D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2005, 2006	Lenny Radtke Football Gazette All-North Region First Team - 2004, 2005 D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2005
Tyke Spencer Football Gazette All-North Region First Team - 2004, 2005 D3football.com All-North Region 2005	Tim Bellazzini Football Gazette All-North Region First Team - 2005, 2006 D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2005 Second Team - 2006	Steve Holden Football Gazette All-North Region Honorable Mention - 2006	Don Kasper D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2005 Second Team - 2006 First Team - 2007
Mario Smith Football Gazette All-North Region Second Team - 2005	Chris Bazant Football Gazette All-North Region Third Team - 2006 D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2006	Matt Spicer Football Gazette All-North Region Honorable Mention - 2006	Eric Stuedemann D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2006
Dominic Sulo Football Gazette All-North Region Honorable Mention - 2006 D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2007 Second Team - 2008	Josh Delancy D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2007 Third Team - 2008 Second Team - 2009	Anthony Imbordino D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2007	Joe Schneiderbauer D3football.com All-North Region Second Team 2007
Matt Wenger D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2007 First Team - 2008, 2010 North Region Defensive Player of the Year - 2010	Kyle Antos D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2008, 2009 First Team - 2010	Aaron Fanthorpe D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2008, 2009	Adam Pucylowski D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2008
Derek Sulo D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2008	Robert Champion D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2009	Kyle Fiedorowicz D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2009 First Team - 2011	Valente Garza D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2010
Joe Antonacci D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2010	Josh McLeod D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2010, 2011	Willie Hayes D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2010	Peter Bulandr D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2011
Josh Mitchell D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2011 Second Team - 2012	Nick Capristo D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2011	Joe Guenther D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2011	Jace Werkheiser D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2011, 2012, 2013
Shane Dierking D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2012 First Team - 2013 North Region Defensive Player of the Year - 2013	Josh Fick D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2012	Nick Kukuc D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2012	Joey Michals D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2012
Tyler Rasche D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2012	Alex Tripp D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2012 First Team - 2013	Nick Slezak D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2013	Spencer Stanek D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2013
Greg Whalen D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2013	Nick Dace D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2013	Peter Sorenson D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2013 Second Team - 2014	Eric Knaperek D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2014 Second Team - 2015
Austin Breunig D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2015 First Team - 2017	Richard Zirngibl D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2015 xxx	Jeremy Niklos D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2016	Broc Rutter D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2016 First Team - 2018, 2019 North Region Offensive Player of the Year - 2018, 2019
Joe Fehrle D3football.com All-North Region Second Team-2016 First Team - 2017	Alex Ulmer D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2016	Billy Douds D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2016	Tommy Sora D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2016, 2017
Emonte Logan D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2017	Andrew Kamienski D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2017 Second Team - 2018 First Team - 2019 D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021	Sharmore Clarke D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2018, 2019 D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021	Tommy Hyland D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2018
Derik Judka D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2018	DJ Warkenthien D3football.com All-North Region Second Team - 2018	Jake Beesley D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2019 D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021	Ethan Greenfield D3football.com All-North Region First Team - 2019 D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021, 2022 D3football.com Region 5 Offensive Player of the Year - 2022
Ricky Strba D3football.com All-North Region Third Team - 2019	Dan Gilroy D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021	Ben Wong D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2021	Braden Lindmark D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2021
Cameron Martin D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2021	DeAngelo Hardy D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2021 First Team - 2022, 2023	Jeske Maples D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2021 First Team - 2022, 2023, 2024	Dan Lester D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2022
Antwain Walker D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2022, 2023	BJ Adamchik D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2022 First Team - 2023, 2024	Sam Pryor D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2022 First Team - 2023, 2024	Tanner Rains D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2022
Jarod Thornton D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2022 First Team - 2023	Terrence Hill D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2022	Julian Bell D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2023	Martin Egbo D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2023
Luke Lehnen D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2023, 2024 Region 5 Offensive Player of the Year - 2023, 2024	Joey Lombardi D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2023	Joe Sacco D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2023 Third Team - 2024	Zack Orr D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2024
Rahmareon Roby D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2024	John Sullivan D3football.com All-Region 5 First Team - 2024 Region 5 Defensive Player of the Year - 2024	Brayden Garrigan D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2024	Cortez Jones D3football.com All-Region 5 Second Team - 2024
Bobby Behmer D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2024	Nick Fehrle D3football.com All-Region 5 Third Team - 2024